2026 Hyundai Santa Fe vs Toyota Highlander

2026 Hyundai Santa Fe

The Santa Fe and the Toyota Highlander are both three-row family SUVs, but they sit at different price points. The Santa Fe starts thousands less and is covered longer, while the Highlander is a bit bigger. Here is how they compare for Carrollton drivers.

The short version: The Santa Fe is the value pick, starting roughly ten thousand dollars less with a much longer warranty and strong efficiency. The Highlander answers with more cargo, more seating, and a higher tow rating. If price and coverage lead, the Santa Fe wins; if you need maximum size, the Highlander earns a look.

Specs side by side

Spec 2026 Hyundai Santa Fe 2026 Toyota Highlander
Powertrains Gas, Hybrid Gas, Hybrid
Horsepower 277 hp gas, 231 hp hybrid 265 hp gas, 243 hp hybrid
Best combined MPG 36 mpg (hybrid) 35 mpg (hybrid)
Drivetrain FWD or HTRAC AWD AWD standard
Seating Up to 7 Up to 8
Cargo behind 3rd row 14.6 cu ft 16.0 cu ft
Max cargo 79.6 cu ft 84.0 cu ft
Max towing up to 4,500 lb (gas) 5,000 lb (gas), 3,500 lb (hybrid)
Basic warranty 5 yr / 60k mi 3 yr / 36k mi
Powertrain warranty 10 yr / 100k mi 5 yr / 60k mi
Hybrid battery warranty 10 yr / 100k mi 10 yr / 150k mi
Starting MSRP $35,050 gas $45,270 (AWD only)

Performance and efficiency

The Santa Fe’s 277 horsepower turbo gas engine tops the Highlander’s 265, while the Highlander Hybrid’s 243 horsepower edges the Santa Fe Hybrid’s 231. Efficiency is close, 36 mpg combined for the Santa Fe Hybrid to 35 for the Highlander Hybrid. Note the Highlander is all-wheel drive only for 2026, while the Santa Fe still offers front-wheel drive for a lower entry price.

Space and practicality

The Highlander is the bigger box, 16 cubic feet behind the third row and 84 maximum, against the Santa Fe’s 14.6 and 79.6, and it seats up to eight to the Santa Fe’s seven. If you regularly fill the third row and the cargo area, the Highlander has the edge.

Towing

The Highlander tows more, up to 5,000 pounds as a gas model to the Santa Fe’s 4,500. Both hybrids are more modest, 3,500 pounds for the Highlander Hybrid and 2,000 for the Santa Fe Hybrid.

Warranty and ownership

The Santa Fe is covered far longer on the big items: 5 years or 60,000 miles basic and 10 years or 100,000 miles powertrain, against the Highlander’s 3 years or 36,000 and 5 years or 60,000. Toyota does cover its hybrid battery longer on miles, 10 years or 150,000 to the Santa Fe’s 10 years or 100,000.

Price and value

This is the Santa Fe’s biggest advantage. It starts at $35,050 for the gas SE, while the 2026 Highlander, now all-wheel drive only, opens at $45,270. That is roughly a ten thousand dollar gap between two similarly sized three-row SUVs.

Which is right for you?

Choose the Santa Fe to save thousands up front and get a much longer warranty. Choose the Highlander if you need the most cargo, eight-seat capacity, or the higher gas tow rating. Come drive the Santa Fe at ALM Carrollton Hyundai.

Santa Fe vs Highlander FAQs

Is the Hyundai Santa Fe or Toyota Highlander better?

The Santa Fe leads on price and warranty; the Highlander leads on size, seating, and towing. The Santa Fe starts about ten thousand dollars less.

Which is cheaper?

The Santa Fe, by a wide margin: $35,050 for the gas SE versus $45,270 for the 2026 Highlander, which is all-wheel drive only.

Which has a better warranty?

The Santa Fe, on basic (5 years or 60,000 miles vs 3 years or 36,000) and powertrain (10 years or 100,000 miles vs 5 years or 60,000). Toyota’s hybrid battery runs longer on miles at 10 years or 150,000.

Which has more cargo and seats?

The Highlander: up to 84 cubic feet maximum and eight seats, versus the Santa Fe’s 79.6 and seven.

Which is more fuel efficient?

The Santa Fe Hybrid, slightly, at up to 36 mpg combined versus 35 for the Highlander Hybrid.

Pricing shown is Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price (MSRP) and excludes destination charges, taxes, title, license, and dealer fees. MSRP is for comparison only and may not reflect actual selling price. Competitor specifications are based on manufacturer and third party data as of October 2026 and are subject to change. Verify details with ALM Carrollton Hyundai before purchase.

Get Directions

3751 Carrollton Villa Rica Highway, Carrollton, GA, 30116

Select Language

Carrollton Hyundai 33.6391046, -84.9724732.